10/13/2005

Zwahiri’s letter to Zarqawi

By: Cao, Filed under: Afghanistan, Iraq & Military , General , Terrorism and Islam @ 2:48 am

The full translation of this letter can be found at Centcom. Zawahiri’s letter to Zarqawi, from the Washington Post, with thanks to Robert Spencer:

Al Qaeda’s top deputy urged the leader of his Iraq branch in July to prepare for the inevitable U.S. withdrawal by carrying out political as well as military actions, and he lectured him that he risked being shunned by an Islamic world angered over his gruesome and not “palatable” killings of fellow Muslims, according to an intercepted letter released yesterday by the U.S. government.

The 6,000-word letter from Osama bin Laden’s chief lieutenant, Ayman Zawahiri, to Iraqi insurgent leader Abu Musab Zarqawi amounts to a detailed portrait of al Qaeda’s long-term goals in Iraq and the Middle East, and includes a striking critique of how Zarqawi has gone about waging his war against not only U.S. troops but also Iraqi civilians….

Invoking the specter of the United States abruptly abandoning Iraq as it did to Vietnam, Zawahiri counseled immediate political action: “We must take the initiative and impose a fait accompli upon our enemies, instead of the enemy imposing one on us.”

The missive also suggests the degree to which al Qaeda’s leadership remains eager to assert its prerogatives with Zarqawi, who has become the increasingly public face of the movement when Zawahiri and bin Laden are in hiding. Although the letter does not contain a direct reference to Zarqawi until a cryptic greeting to him at the end, a senior intelligence official who briefed reporters on the condition of anonymity said “it’s absolutely certain” it was meant for Zarqawi, declining to elaborate on how U.S. officials made that conclusion. The letter was dated July 9, but the official would not say whether it had been sent. “We obtained it in the course of counterterrorism operations in Iraq,” he said.

Throughout, Zawahiri — the Egyptian doctor who fused his own Islamic movement with bin Laden’s al Qaeda in the late 1990s and is believed to operate now as the group’s top commander — comes across as a strategist trying to rein in a guerrilla operating at odds with the movement’s political goals. The official said that in its repeated criticism of Zarqawi, the letter also amounts to a reproof from “an al Qaeda elder to an occasionally hotheaded field commander.”

“He comes down like a ton of bricks on what has happened tactically,” the official said.

“This is not a rant. It is more chilling in a sense because it’s so well-argued, clean and calm,” the official added. “There’s a high political content. Zawahiri calls for political action equivalent to military action.”

There seem to be, according to Centcom, seven critical themes which can be drawn from the Zawahiri-Zarqawi letter. The first four confirm al-Qaida’s long-term strategy and core beliefs; the latter three reflect new information about how senior al-Qaida leader Zawahiri views developments in Iraq – and elsewhere – turning against them.

The letter demonstrates that pulling US forces out of Iraq is the wrong approachthat terrorists will not simply lay down their arms when American forces depart Iraq . Al-Qaida and its terrorist brethren will not go away when the Coalition hands over security control to Iraqi forces; rather, they are committed to overthrowing the elected, democratic Iraqi government and ruling the country according to their interpretation of Islamic law.

Quote: “And it is that the Mujahidin must not have their mission end with the expulsion of the Americans from Iraq , and then lay down their weapons, and silence the fighting zeal. We will return to having the secularists and traitors holding sway over us.”

Zawahiri believes in religious intolerance and converting, conquering, or killing anyone who does not believe as he does. His only concern is how to deceive the population that this is not the case by urging Zarqawi to reduce attacks on Shia civilians. Zawahiri contends that Shia are heretics. He views Shi’ism as a “religious school based on excess and falsehood,” and as a danger to what he sees as true, Sunni Islam. Zawahiri does not condemn Zarqawi for killing Shia. Indeed, the Shia, along with anyone who does not blindly follow al-Qaida’s twisted interpretation of Islam, will be forced either to adopt al-Qa’ida’s extremist ideology or face repression or death if the terrorists establish control. Zawahiri’s concerns are purely tactical; managing the press and gaining the support, or acquiescence, of the people.

Quote: “People of discernment and knowledge among Muslims know the extent of danger to Islam of the 12’er school of Shi’ism. It is a religious school based on excess and falsehood whose function is to accuse the companions of Muhammad of heresy [in] a campaign against Islam, in order to free the way for a group of those who call for a dialogue in the name of the hidden mahdi who is in control of existence and infallible in what he does. Their prior history in cooperating with the enemies of Islam is consistent with their current reality of connivance with the crusaders.”


al-Qaida views the developments in Iraq – and elsewhere – as turning against them:

Zawahiri clearly is worried they are losing public support in Iraq, and is attuned to the role of the media in the battle for such support. Zawahiri emphasizes that the struggle is ideological, with each side competing for the popular support and loyalty of the Muslim world. Zarqawi’s methods are backfiring by alienating the Iraqi people with attacks against the Shia.

Quote: “…[W]e will see that the strongest weapon which the Mujahidin enjoy . . . is popular support from the Muslim masses in Iraq , and the surrounding Muslim countries. So, we must maintain this support as best we can, and we should strive to increase it….”

Quote: “[T]he Jihadist movement must avoid any action that the masses do not understand or approve. . . .”

Quote: “I say to you: that we are in a battle, and that more than half this battle is taking place in the battlefield of the media. And that we are in a media battle in a race for the hearts and minds of our nation.”

Zawahiri, who previously termed democracy heretical, is willing to exploit the political process unfolding in Iraq to advance the group’s goals. Zawahiri is advocating a modified strategy in an attempt to expand the group’s Sunni support base in Iraq . It is tacit acknowledgement that the political process unfolding in Iraq appeals to average Iraqis. Zarqawi’s recent pronouncements for all-out war against the Shia and recent rhetoric against Sunnis supporting the government and coalition stirred concerns among his advisers and allies and already have prompted Zarqawi to quickly adjust his rhetoric and some tactics.

The English version of the letter is here.

10 Responses to “Zwahiri’s letter to Zarqawi”

  1. Speed of Thought Says:

    The Zawahiri letter…

    You have no doubt heard about the Zawahiri letter. Chad has a very interesting analysis of it that you should read.

  2. SPC C. Flowers Says:

    Hi, Caoilfhionn:

    I just wanted to thank you for linking to the US Central Command website. Your support and interest are appreciated.

    We also have a number of previous “What Extremists Are Saying” news items posted in our archive at http://www.centcom.mil/Archives_extremistssay.htm.

    Thanks again!

    –SPC C. Flowers
    CENTCOM Public Affairs

  3. Stop The ACLU Says:

    Bin Laden’s Letter

    A 6,000 word letter from Osama bin Laden’s second-in-command to al-Qaida’s leader in Iraq outlines the terrorist group’s strategy to oust American troops from Iraq, create a militant Islamic state there, use that as a base to overthr…

  4. Cao Says:

    Spc Flowers, I am all over everything you have over there, I’m grateful that there is another resource for information on the messages that Al Q is putting out…this is information that the MSM doesn’t convey–and I think the American people are missing out on the REAL story in Iraq. Thank you for posting that!

  5. SSgt Yatahey Says:

    I’ve been an active subscriber to the US Central Command website for over a year - they do have some terrific info each week! :cool:

  6. Don Surber Says:

    Good News From Iraq, See Page A13

    Cao’s Blog also comments on the letter. But also read Cao’s The ACLU and Terrorism Today. I don’t question anyone’s loyalty or patriotism. But could we just put aside the cauterwauling over personal liberties for five minutes to listen to the need …

  7. Don Singleton Says:

    What Extremists Are Saying

    Both want the Shia dead. Zarqawi wants them to die in a civil war now, Zawahiri wants to wait until he controls the country.

  8. Timmer ~ Righting America Says:

    Centcom is right on with their assesments as well.

    As I have written also, the thing that struck me the most about the letter was Zawahiri’s seemingly (and hopefully) desperate hope that we will repeat our mistakes of Vietnam. Like everyone else in the world who is paying attention, he sees our own politicians and celebrities caving in - and it is indeed assailing the American will to continue (reminiscent of 30-some years ago).

    His worst fears are that this President and the American military will continue with the mission, as promised. Without the collaps of our national will, al-Qaieda stands no chance of gaining a sanctuary in the Middle East.

    Great blog!

  9. Pursuing Holiness » Blog Archive » Speaking of reality - the Coalition of the Googlin’ Says:

    […] This is a PR war, and we are losing. Someday there may be a museum in Iran or Wahhabist Saudi Arabia that acknowledges the contributions of Rep. John Murtha and his Democratic colleagues, along with the vast majority of our media, in establishing the global caliphate. Zwahiri acknowledged that more than half the battle is taking place in the battlefield of the media. […]

  10. Dummocrats Says:

    World Caliphate Museum Exhibit Opens

    Fill in the blanks in this future news article - post your nominations in the comments. ————————————————————————————- 7/26/1452 Anno Hegirae (11/21/2030 Anno Domini) MECCA (Al Jazeerah) - World Ca…

Leave a Reply